Pizza Heaven is a well-established Italian restaurant located in New Windsor, NY. Renowned as the “Home of the Giant Slice,” this popular eatery has become a staple in the community. Since its founding in 1993, this family-owned pizzeria has proudly served generations of customers, earning a reputation for its generous, large New York-style pizza and comforting homemade Italian dishes. Over the past three decades, Pizza Heaven has cultivated a loyal following by consistently offering delicious food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere that feels like a second home.
The menu highlights high-quality ingredients and features flavors reminiscent of home cooking. Their signature dish is a large single slice of pizza, often described as equivalent to 2.5 regular slices. Popular choices among customers include the White Pizza, Taco Pizza—which is widely celebrated as a local favorite—and Buffalo Chicken. Beyond pizza, the menu also includes delicious pepperoni rolls and flavorful chicken dishes.
This pizza place offers a relaxed, welcoming, family-friendly environment where guests can enjoy a comfortable and casual dining experience. Visitors often praise the generous portion sizes, the friendly and attentive staff, and the distinctive “NYC-style” crust that sets their pizzas apart. The pizzeria has also been recognized for its quality, earning the title of Orange County’s top pizzeria at one point.
Map/Directions/Reviews
Share this!
032426
